4.0 draft 3 published – final comment period underway - Creative Commons
Skip to content
“… Civile”
umjanedoan
CC BY
It’s a fitting start to CC’s
second decade
as a license steward that we are publishing for comment the
third and final draft of version 4.0
This draft has been long in the making, but we think it’s all the better for the extended discussion and drafting period, and therefore that much closer to finalization and realizing its full potential as an international license suite.
New in Draft 3
Much of our attention since
publishing draft 2
has been focused on improving the license in ways tied to
key objectives
we had in mind when
this process started
a little more than a year ago.
Sui generis database rights – a weighty factor in our decision to version – are now handled more thoroughly and clearly. The
changes introduced in draft 3
will be of particular benefit for data projects and communities forced to manage the complexities of licensing those rights in addition to copyright. The 4.0 suite will provide more certainty about application of the license and the obligations of re-users of data where those right apply. The revisions also reinforce CC’s policy of
combatting the expansion of sui generis database rights
beyond the borders of the few countries where they exist. Those rights and obligations remain safely confined.
Interoperability
has been a second, important objective of this versioning process. Our
BY
and
BY-NC
licenses have never specified how adaptations may be licensed. This is a source of confusion at times for users, especially for those remixing materials under a variety of licenses whether within or external to the CC suite. In draft 3, we have
introduced provisions
specifying how contributions to adaptations built from BY and BY-NC licensed material must be licensed. The rule we introduce should be intuitive for most (and has always been true), and will be easily recognized by others because of its foundation in copyright. We are eager to hear feedback on whether it’s a workable rule in practice. If so, then these new provisions will clear the way for increased interoperability between those two licenses and other public licenses.
We have also introduced a number of features to better ensure that works can be reused as the licenses (and licensors) intend. We recognize that licensors are often required or encouraged to apply technological protection measures when distributing their works through large platforms, and that those TPMs can prevent the public from using the CC-licensed work as the license permits (reproduce, modify, share, etc.). The
license is now clear
that if users choose to circumvent those measures in order to exercise rights the CC licenses grant, the licensor may not object. In some situations others (such as the platform provider)
may have the right to object
, and in some circumstances and jurisdictions doing may still be a criminal offense. Our licenses do not help in those situations (and should not be relied upon to protect users in those cases). But at least between licensors and those reusers, circumvention is expressly authorized.
Several other changes have been introduced to improve the smooth functioning of the licenses, including a few worth highlighting here:
Although we have decided not to pursue a proposal that would have required licensors to offer
representations and warranties
, we now prominently highlight important before-licensing considerations that encourage rights clearances and proper marking of third-party content. These practices and considerations have long been
promoted by CC
. Placing them in closer proximity to the licenses educates licensors and encourages responsible licensing practices, and alerts the public to the limitations of the licenses.
The license now includes a mechanism that allows for
automatic reinstatement
of the license when a violation is cured within 30 days of discovery, while preserving a licensor’s right to seek remedies for those violations. This was a popular request, particularly by institutions wanting to use high-quality CC-licensed content in important contexts but who worried about losing their license permanently for an inadvertent violation.
Public Discussion – Featured Topics
In this
third discussion period
, we will be returning our attention to
ShareAlike compatibility
, the centerpiece of our interoperability agenda. We will take a harder look at the mechanism necessary to permit
one-way compatibility
out from BY-SA to other similarly spirited licenses like GPLv3, and whether one-way compatibility is, in fact, desired. We will also develop compatibility criteria and processes, though that may not conclude until after the 4.0 suite is launched. We expect to explore the introduction of a compatibility mechanism in BY-NC-SA similar to that already present in BY-SA. Draft 3 incorporates the changes that would accomplish all of this, if the decision is made to pursue these actions following vetting with our community.
Internationalization will also be a highlight of this discussion period. We will be making a final push with our legal affiliates to fine tune the legal code so the licenses operate as intended and are enforceable around the world. As part of this, we expect a full discussion on the
new interpretation clause
that establishes a default rule for how the license should be interpreted.
Other topics we will be covering include
attribution
and some finessing of those requirements. And as publication time draws nearer, we will also be having discussions about the
license deed and related matters
. You can find a complete list of
open topics
a list of changes in draft 3
and a side-by-side comparison of
Draft 2 and Draft 3
(237 KB PDF) on our 4.0 wiki, as well as
downloads and links
to all six draft licenses.
We look forward to hearing from you in this final comment stage. Check out all
six of the 4.0d3 licenses
, and join the
CC license development and versioning list
, or contribute ideas directly to the
4.0 wiki
Thanks again for a productive comment period. Thanks for the many valuable contributions to date!
Posted 14 February 2013
Tags
Weblog
You might also like...