Apple v. Samsung: A patent battle with freedom as the collateral damage — Free Software Foundation — Working together for free software
Skip to content
or
skip to search
You
are here:
Blogs
Licensing
Apple v. Samsung: A patent battle with freedom as the collateral damage
Info
Apple v. Samsung: A patent battle with freedom as the collateral damage
by
Donald Robertson
Contributions
Published on
Sep 21, 2012 06:22 PM
Apple's patent aggression harms us all.
Since Samsung was
found liable for infringing some of Apple's mobile patents
[PDF] on August 24th, 2012, there has been widespread anger directed at Apple. Many people rightly note that Apple's strong-arming of Samsung harms free software users everywhere and mobile users in particular. Phones and tablets could be banned from the market, and there will certainly be a chilling effect on free software development in the area. Apple's victory here is our collective loss, as the ruling magnifies the damaging effects of Apple's proprietary systems.
Using software patents as a weapon, Apple is restricting mobile devices that eschew its
escalating systems of digital restrictions management
. Apple is also effectively trying to lock users into devices that cannot easily install free software, trapping them within its App Store which
does not permit the distribution of GPL licensed works
. This ruling will also help block replacements for Apple's iPad being distributed to students, a
disastrous consequence for educators
The damage from this ruling, however, goes beyond the realm of mobile devices. The software patents involved could potentially dominate a large swath of free software. Even prior to this verdict, free software projects like GNUstep were so threatened by the specter of such patents that they were not able to accept contributions related to multi-touch.
Apple v. Samsung
crystallizes the threat that software patents already pose to everyone, everywhere. The problems with the patent system, such as absurdities like patents on "pinch to zoom," will persist as long as the Patent Office is allowed to grant software patents.
Google (via Motorola) recently filed
a suit against Apple
[PDF] as a defensive response to Apple's actions, which will also have disastrous consequences for everyone else involved. Many people are hopeful that these ridiculous lawsuits will be so damaging as to cause a "software patent apocalypse"; that they will somehow force change to the patent system merely by their destructiveness. While we can hope that change could result, the problem is that we have no way of knowing what direction that change would take. Current congressional responses to patent dysfunction, like
the Shield Act
, show that while representatives are starting to understand that the system is broken, they do not see the right way to fix it.
Instead of waiting on a possible "apocalypse," we need to take action now to end software patents:
Please join us in our campaign against software patents at
. You should also join the campaign
mailing list
to stay up-to-date.
Help stop software patents from being forced onto Europe by the European Patent Office by joining
April's action against software patents
Check out our film on the preposterous state of the patent system:
Patent Absurdity: how software patents broke the system
For more information on ending software patents, please see our
End Software Patents Wiki
You can also support our future work against software patents by
making a donation
to the FSF.
Document Actions
Share on social networks
Syndicate:
News
Events
Blogs
Jobs
GNU
1PC9aZC4hNX2rmmrt7uHTfYAS3hRbph4UN
Plan a LibreLocal 2026 meetup!
You can help build the
free software
community, and it's as
simple
as organizing a
meetup
at your favorite cafe or bar.
FSF community blog
Licensing Compliance Lab blog
Associate Membership blog
System Administrator's blog
Free Software Directory blog
GNU Press blog
News
Job opportunity: Engineering and Certification Manager at the Free Software Foundation
Mar 10, 2026
The FSF announces global call for FSF's LibreLocal 2026 meetups
Feb 24, 2026
Eko K. A. Owen joins the FSF board as the union staff pick
Dec 29, 2025
More news…
Recent blogs
RAIL: Nonfree and unethical
You cannot use the GNU (A)GPL to take software freedom away
Relicensing versus license compatibility
March GNU Spotlight with Amin Bandali featuring eighteen new GNU releases: Autoconf, PSPP, and more!
Recent blogs -
More…
Upcoming Events
Free Software Directory meeting on IRC: Friday, April 24, starting at 12:00 EDT (16:00 UTC)
Apr 24, 2026 12:00 PM - 03:00 PM
#fsf on libera.chat
LibreLocal meetup in Beijing, China
May 01, 2026 02:00 PM - 09:00 PM
META SPACE Coffee&Bar, Dong Sheng Yuan Gong Yu, Heqing St., Haidian District, Beijing
Previous events…
Upcoming events…
The FSF is a charity with a worldwide mission to advance software freedom —
learn about our history and work.
fsf.org is powered by:
Plone
Zope
Python
CiviCRM
HTML5