Peter Suber, Open Access News

Peter Suber, Open Access News
Open Access News
News from the open access movement
Jump to
Monday, December 03, 2007
New data showing that most OA journals charge no publication fees
Bill Hooker,
If it won't sink in, maybe we can pound it in...
Open Reading Frame
, December 2, 2007.
First Bill recaps existing evidence (1) that
most OA journals charge no author-side fees
, and (2) that a larger percentage of
TA
journals charges such fees than do OA journals.  I'm very grateful to see him hammering on this issue, which I've been doing nearly alone for two years.  But he goes further and adds new evidence:
All of the above got me to wondering what proportion of journals in the entire DOAJ database charge author-side fees (since Suber and Sutton showed that when the dataset was expanded, at least among society publishers, the no-fee percentage went up considerably).
Fortunately, the DOAJ now includes a metadata field indicating whether or not a particular journal charges author-side publication fees. Unfortunately, that field is not included in the downloadable comma-delimited metadata file they make available. Fortunately, it's not a whole lot of work to make a replacement file by copy-and-pasting from the "browse by title" page. Unfortunately, you have to do this from the new "for authors" section, because the front-page browsing interface doesn't include the "fee/no fee" field. What's unfortunate about that, for my purposes (though it's a wonderful thing overall), is that the "for authors" browse
does
include hybrid journals, in which regular articles are subscription-only but authors can pay extra to have their work made OA. (In fact, even the logo at the top is different; on the front page you are seeing the Directory of Open Access Journals, but in the "for authors" section it becomes the Directory of Open Access and Hybrid Journals.) The front page says 2971 journals are indexed, but if you browse by title from the "for authors" page, the totals add up to 4638, the database having apparently added 1667 hybrid journals.
There's probably a smarter way to do this using the
OAI-PMH
, but that syntax is as impenetrable to me as Ancient High Martian, so I simply pasted the browse-by-title pages into a text document and imported that (colon-delimited) into Excel. Then I filtered on "publication fees", sorted by yes/no/missing and read off the totals from the row numbers. Horrible hack, but it worked.
Including hybrid journals, we get:
charge publication fees: 2185 (47%)
don't charge pub fees: 1998 (43%)
fee information missing: 455 (10%)
total no. of journals: 4638
Given the DOAJ definition of hybrid journal, those should obviously be excluded and the data reworked. This is where a smart person would have stopped and waited for the DOAJ to autogenerate the numbers, but I went ahead and deleted the hybrid entries by hand. (Shut up. I wanted to know, OK?) That yields:
charge publication fees: 534 (18%)
don't charge pub fees: 1980 (67%)
fee information missing: 453 (15%)
total no. of journals: 2967
The second total should presumably be 2971 and it would make sense for the "missing" totals to be the same in both sets, so either there are some errors in the database or I made a couple myself. In either case the errors appear small and make no difference to the percentages, and anyway did I mention this kept me up to 4 am? Actually I suspect some inconsistencies in the database, because the front-page total does not update as quickly as the actual entries, and because there are in fact hybrid journals which don't charge fees (e.g.
Emerald Engineering's model
).
So now we have three studies (OK, two studies and one ungainly hack) showing that a (strong) majority of OA journals do not charge author-side fees, and one of those studies further showing that a strong majority of non-full-OA journals do in fact charge author-side in addition to subscription fees.
Now, can we please put to rest the myth/FUD/whatever that there is only one OA model, the author-side fees/PLoS model? While we're at it, let's have a few more closely related ideas go the way of the dodo: that OA journals discriminate against indigent authors (because they charge publication fees -- except that most of them don't); that OA journals will compromise on quality (in order to collect payment for manuscripts -- except that most of them don't); that if most journals went OA, universities would have to pay more in author-side fees (which, remember, most OA journals don't, but most non-OA journals do, charge) than they do now in subscription fees.
I swiped that list of candidates for memetic extinction from Peter Suber, and you should go read his
full discussion
, which offers a lot more detail, especially on that last point. Me, I'm going to take a nap and go back to my blog hiatus. But the next time you hear someone talk about the "cost" of publishing in OA journals, please point 'em here.
Posted by
Peter Suber at 12/03/2007 09:18:00 AM.
The open access movement:
Putting peer-reviewed scientific and scholarly literature
on the internet. Making it available free of charge and
free of most copyright and licensing restrictions.
Removing the barriers to serious research.
Why the OAN volume has been low
since January 16, 2010
Why I curtailed my blogging
on July 1, 2009
recommend
the
OA tracking project
(OATP) as the best way to stay on top of new OA developments.  You can read the
OATP feed
on a blog-like
web page
or subscribe to it by
RSS
email
, or
.  You can also help build the feed by
tagging
new developments you encounter.
New
to the concept of open access? See my
Open
Access Overview
Skip
over links
Peter Suber
, Editor
About
this blog
This blog is more news than comment. For more comment than
news, see my
writings
on OA
Links open new windows
Related pages & services
Overview
Forum
Timeline
Events
Blogroll
Wiki
See
what you can
do
to help the cause of open access.
Are all your articles about OA themselves OA? If not,
here's
how to
change that
Wanted:
True stories illustrating the
benefits of open access or the harms caused by the lack
of it.
Details
Feeds for
all
OAN posts
Atom feed
RSS feed
Email feed (via
Feedburner
Audio feed (via
Jott
Feeds for
hot
OAN posts (
note
RSS feed
Email feed (via
Feedburner
Audio feed (via
Jott
May 26, 2002
June 2, 2002
June 9, 2002
June 16, 2002
June 23, 2002
June 30, 2002
July 7, 2002
July 14, 2002
July 21, 2002
July 28, 2002
August 4, 2002
August 11, 2002
August 18, 2002
August 25, 2002
September 1, 2002
September 8, 2002
September 15, 2002
September 22, 2002
September 29, 2002
October 6, 2002
October 13, 2002
October 20, 2002
October 27, 2002
November 3, 2002
November 10, 2002
November 17, 2002
November 24, 2002
December 1, 2002
December 8, 2002
December 15, 2002
December 22, 2002
December 29, 2002
January 5, 2003
January 12, 2003
January 19, 2003
January 26, 2003
February 2, 2003
February 9, 2003
February 16, 2003
February 23, 2003
March 2, 2003
March 9, 2003
March 16, 2003
March 23, 2003
March 30, 2003
April 6, 2003
April 13, 2003
April 20, 2003
April 27, 2003
May 4, 2003
May 11, 2003
May 18, 2003
May 25, 2003
June 1, 2003
June 8, 2003
June 15, 2003
June 22, 2003
June 29, 2003
July 6, 2003
July 13, 2003
July 20, 2003
July 27, 2003
August 3, 2003
August 10, 2003
August 17, 2003
August 24, 2003
August 31, 2003
September 7, 2003
September 14, 2003
September 21, 2003
September 28, 2003
October 5, 2003
October 12, 2003
October 19, 2003
October 26, 2003
November 2, 2003
November 9, 2003
November 16, 2003
November 23, 2003
November 30, 2003
December 7, 2003
December 14, 2003
December 21, 2003
December 28, 2003
January 4, 2004
January 11, 2004
January 18, 2004
January 25, 2004
February 1, 2004
February 8, 2004
February 15, 2004
February 22, 2004
February 29, 2004
March 7, 2004
March 14, 2004
March 21, 2004
March 28, 2004
April 4, 2004
April 11, 2004
April 18, 2004
April 25, 2004
May 2, 2004
May 9, 2004
May 16, 2004
May 23, 2004
May 30, 2004
June 6, 2004
June 13, 2004
June 20, 2004
June 27, 2004
July 4, 2004
July 11, 2004
July 18, 2004
July 25, 2004
August 1, 2004
August 8, 2004
August 15, 2004
August 22, 2004
August 29, 2004
September 5, 2004
September 12, 2004
September 19, 2004
September 26, 2004
October 3, 2004
October 10, 2004
October 17, 2004
October 24, 2004
October 31, 2004
November 7, 2004
November 14, 2004
November 21, 2004
November 28, 2004
December 5, 2004
December 12, 2004
December 19, 2004
December 26, 2004
January 2, 2005
January 9, 2005
January 16, 2005
January 23, 2005
January 30, 2005
February 6, 2005
February 13, 2005
February 20, 2005
February 27, 2005
March 6, 2005
March 13, 2005
March 20, 2005
March 27, 2005
April 3, 2005
April 10, 2005
April 17, 2005
April 24, 2005
May 1, 2005
May 8, 2005
May 15, 2005
May 22, 2005
May 29, 2005
June 5, 2005
June 12, 2005
June 19, 2005
June 26, 2005
July 3, 2005
July 10, 2005
July 17, 2005
July 24, 2005
July 31, 2005
August 7, 2005
August 14, 2005
August 21, 2005
August 28, 2005
September 4, 2005
September 11, 2005
September 18, 2005
September 25, 2005
October 2, 2005
October 9, 2005
October 16, 2005
October 23, 2005
October 30, 2005
November 6, 2005
November 13, 2005
November 20, 2005
November 27, 2005
December 4, 2005
December 11, 2005
December 18, 2005
December 25, 2005
January 1, 2006
January 8, 2006
January 15, 2006
January 22, 2006
January 29, 2006
February 5, 2006
February 12, 2006
February 19, 2006
February 26, 2006
March 5, 2006
March 12, 2006
March 19, 2006
March 26, 2006
April 2, 2006
April 9, 2006
April 16, 2006
April 23, 2006
April 30, 2006
May 7, 2006
May 14, 2006
May 21, 2006
May 28, 2006
June 4, 2006
June 11, 2006
June 18, 2006
June 25, 2006
July 2, 2006
July 9, 2006
July 16, 2006
July 23, 2006
July 30, 2006
August 6, 2006
August 13, 2006
August 20, 2006
August 27, 2006
September 3, 2006
September 10, 2006
September 17, 2006
September 24, 2006
October 1, 2006
October 8, 2006
October 15, 2006
October 22, 2006
October 29, 2006
November 5, 2006
November 12, 2006
November 19, 2006
November 26, 2006
December 3, 2006
December 10, 2006
December 17, 2006
December 24, 2006
December 31, 2006
January 7, 2007
January 14, 2007
January 21, 2007
January 28, 2007
February 4, 2007
February 11, 2007
February 18, 2007
February 25, 2007
March 4, 2007
March 11, 2007
March 18, 2007
March 25, 2007
April 1, 2007
April 8, 2007
April 15, 2007
April 22, 2007
April 29, 2007
May 6, 2007
May 13, 2007
May 20, 2007
May 27, 2007
June 3, 2007
June 10, 2007
June 17, 2007
June 24, 2007
July 1, 2007
July 8, 2007
July 15, 2007
July 22, 2007
July 29, 2007
August 5, 2007
August 12, 2007
August 19, 2007
August 26, 2007
September 2, 2007
September 9, 2007
September 16, 2007
September 23, 2007
September 30, 2007
October 7, 2007
October 14, 2007
October 21, 2007
October 28, 2007
November 4, 2007
November 11, 2007
November 18, 2007
November 25, 2007
December 2, 2007
December 9, 2007
December 16, 2007
December 23, 2007
December 30, 2007
January 6, 2008
January 13, 2008
January 20, 2008
January 27, 2008
February 3, 2008
February 10, 2008
February 17, 2008
February 24, 2008
March 2, 2008
March 9, 2008
March 16, 2008
March 23, 2008
March 30, 2008
April 6, 2008
April 13, 2008
April 20, 2008
April 27, 2008
May 4, 2008
May 11, 2008
May 18, 2008
May 25, 2008
June 1, 2008
June 8, 2008
June 15, 2008
June 22, 2008
June 29, 2008
July 6, 2008
July 13, 2008
July 20, 2008
July 27, 2008
August 3, 2008
August 10, 2008
August 17, 2008
August 24, 2008
August 31, 2008
September 7, 2008
September 14, 2008
September 21, 2008
September 28, 2008
October 5, 2008
October 12, 2008
October 19, 2008
October 26, 2008
November 2, 2008
November 9, 2008
November 16, 2008
November 23, 2008
November 30, 2008
December 7, 2008
December 14, 2008
December 21, 2008
December 28, 2008
January 4, 2009
January 11, 2009
January 18, 2009
January 25, 2009
February 1, 2009
February 8, 2009
February 15, 2009
February 22, 2009
March 1, 2009
March 8, 2009
March 15, 2009
March 22, 2009
March 29, 2009
April 5, 2009
April 12, 2009
April 19, 2009
April 26, 2009
May 3, 2009
May 10, 2009
May 17, 2009
May 24, 2009
May 31, 2009
June 7, 2009
June 14, 2009
June 21, 2009
June 28, 2009
July 5, 2009
July 12, 2009
August 2, 2009
August 9, 2009
August 16, 2009
August 23, 2009
August 30, 2009
September 6, 2009
September 13, 2009
September 20, 2009
September 27, 2009
October 4, 2009
October 11, 2009
October 18, 2009
October 25, 2009
November 1, 2009
November 8, 2009
November 15, 2009
November 22, 2009
November 29, 2009
December 6, 2009
December 13, 2009
December 20, 2009
December 27, 2009
January 3, 2010
January 10, 2010
January 31, 2010
February 14, 2010
February 28, 2010
March 28, 2010
URLinfo
for
Open
Access News
Blogarama
Open
Access News
is supported by the
Open Society
Institute
, the
Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition
, and the
Wellcome Trust
Where are the OAN readers?